Okay I am fed up with how difficult is to download Images (attachments) from Airtable

General Discussion
1

Yes, I know I can use Zapier or Make. That is complicated, every time I setup a new attachment field, I got to setup a new workflow ?? Madness.
It’s 2023 and Airtable didn’t manage to add a single “Download all attachments” button. I understand that is taxing their servers, so they can give me a slow download at least, that’s fine. Are they doing it on purpose, now starting thinking perhaps :unamused:

Yes, I know they are extensions for that too. And it is either free up to 10 records per day (miniextensions), or it is 4 dollar per month (another extension) or then 50 dollar per month if you have miniextensions.

That may work for some but how about try to download completely free. This shouldn’t be something I need to pay for.

This assumes you have generated expiring URLs using automation.

I came up with 2 ways. Well, it’s not completely convenient but it is pretty okay.

  1. the Easy way…

Download Chrome extension Simple Mass Downloader …

There you can setup either:

a) copy the URLs from the table and past into the extension (load clipboard) and download links
b) you can also open detail view of the record and download attachments you need (use filter to filter only attachments and images that have “airtableuserconcent” in the URL)

  1. The better way… (here is soltuion if you are on Mac, but Windows has scripts too):

Here is a small script in Automator on MacOS. When executed, it will read the clipboard and save links.

These 2 methods can download any number of records. The only issue all downloads will be in one folder without knowing which attachment is for what record.

Anybody has other ideas how to download the attachments download in bulk?

There are other Chrome extensions allowing you also to rename attachments or adding prefix or adding a subfolder while they are downloaded but this slows down the process.

Automator should be able to prompt me for a download folder name or suffix in a dialogue popup asking for input, but I haven’t figured out how to do it and it still does slow down downloads a bit because that would be download by individual record.

Still better than downloading each image/attachment manually.

image
image985×813 29.9 KB

Another option is to use a download manager like Motrix if you are on MacOS and past the links. This just downloads the images without the option to decide about the file name or subdirectory.

image
image906×263 11.4 KB

2

Why are you constantly downloading attachments in bulk from your Airtable base?

This is not a common use case, and Airtable has specifically said that they are not to be used as a CDN or image hosting service.

Have you considered looking into Google Drive or Dropbox or Cloudinary or other cloud based services that can store images?

If you’re trying to backup your images from Airtable, then you can turn to On2Air Backups, or you can very easily setup an automation in Make.com to download all of your images.

I also do not subscribe to your philosophy that people should give me the software tools that I want for free.

1 Like
3

First of all, I am not saying it. Why do you believe I said that? I just have listed the options. If I am inclining to free solution, it doesn’t mean my philosophy is to expect others to give me free software. That is far stretched a bit. It’s my courtesy to mention them here and list them, free advertising to them and help to others who need to decide. So no need to pick it apart at this detail.

I’m already on Cloudinary but for different purpose, use it for production images while fixing the attachment before going live.

I don’t like to have to setup a workflow via Make and Zapier to add the links from Cloudinary. When I add new attachment field I have to go to fix the flow or make new one. There’s no integration vial cloudinary directly in Airtable unless there is something new.

I am deleting and adding attachments frequently in Airtable but once I am happy with the record, I only download them once or upload them to another hosting once.

Pictures are taken only via Airtable mobile app.

Cloudinary does not meet purpose as document management, their interface is okay for managing assets.

If 3rd party can download in bulk, there isn’t a problem for Airtable to install a button for each record to download all images in the field. That is what I am talking about.

4

I understand your frustration but I’d agree with Scott here that your use case is not a very common use case (I’ve literally built thousands of bases/apps on Airtable and never faced such a requirement) and Airtable were upfront and honest that their solution is not to be used as a CDN. So I don’t think your demands for Airtable are justified here.

1 Like
5

Please explain me what is CDN. Maybe I need help with that.

If the attachments in the field is not to be downloaded in bulk, then I would desire an easier handling.

image

For example Baserow, easy click click click, they are all within the reach.

It’s almost addictive to download images in Baserow.

Clicking and downloading images from the Airtable field takes way longer for me. Or download documents, whatever is attached.

Even downloading 3 images is frustrating experience if I do it a few times per day. Nothing bothers me as much as this in Airtable.

Okay, perhaps I am using Airtable in the wrong way, or not permitted way / not intended way.

I think we all like to save time and do things the most convenient way.

I would pick Airtable over Baserow handsdown and image and attachment handling in Airtable is perfect otherwise.

I am not complaining about anything else other than a download button.

Another example, if I may. I know I am starting to sound like an annoying pest. I am sorry. I’ll shut up now.

Here is Noco. There is even a convenient BULK download button. How intriguing, apparently they figured that out already.

image
image781×580 55.7 KB

Okay.

Here is another example.

The much promoted SmartSuite here in the forum.

image
image831×329 36.2 KB

There.
What a lovely Bulk download button there.

I am not going to continue. Hope this clarifies the point I was trying to make. But I agree … .I AM using Airtable the wrong way, possibly.

But I am not using Airtable images of files as a share hoster. I am the only person who has access to the attachments.

Peace

6

There are many things that third party tools do that Airtable has not decided to implement as native functionality. You are free to submit feature requests directly to Airtable and to suggest them here, but I wouldn’t count on seeing this feature any time soon.

I think you want to use Airtable in a way that is not directly supported (bulk downloading of attachments). This doesn’t meant that you you are doing is wrong. But it also means that you cannot do that natively.

In general, Airtable does not want to make it easy for people to move off-platform. Bulk downloading of attachments would make it easier to move off-platform, and it is not a common use case, so Airtable has decided to not put resources into developing that feature.

Oh, and I agree that you are not using Airtable as a CDN. That is an unrelated concept.

It sounds like you are downloading files to your local computer as an intermediary step to get your files to their final destination (Cloudinary)

Have you considered using a script to upload files directly from Airtable to Cloudinary? You could set the attachment field in the script settings, or have the script prompt you for a field.

You could also have a generic Make scenario that is triggered by a webhook and called by an Airtable script. Whenever you have a new attachment field, point the script to the new field. That way you would not have to change the Make scenario when you add/delete an attachment field.

7

Yes and no, I do use Make and Cloudinary to process 1 image and then goes back go Airtable.

I download images when I need to upload them to another site that doesn’t have an API, so it requires manual upload.

I agree, Airtable does not want to make easy for people to move off-platform. It may actually back-fire. IT people in particularly will ask the first question when debating a platform they have no control - can the data be easily exported?

Being able to export all images attached to one specific field manually by clicking a button is not a moving-off-platform strategy. Imagine doing it 100,000 times.

With permission I add this to the feature requests we have in this forum already, it seems that is best place where to make a note of it permanently since I don’t think there is an attended suggestions @ Airtable .com mailbox.